Skip to main content
How to Hire a HOA / Association Manager: A Guide for Employers

How to Hire a HOA / Association Manager: A Guide for Employers

Most bad association manager hires trace back to a vague job description. A board writes "manage the community" and a management company writes "handle our portfolio," then each is surprised when the new hire turns out to be strong at vendor coordination but uncomfortable at a contentious annual meeting, or the reverse. Before you post anything, you need to know what the person will actually do, who they will answer to, and which skills you can teach versus which you must hire for.

This process works whether you are a self-managed association hiring directly or a management company filling a portfolio seat. The steps are the same: scope the role, source candidates, screen carefully, interview against a scorecard, verify, and onboard with intent.

Define the Job Before You Post It

Decide Who the Employer Is

An association manager can work for a management company that contracts with many communities, or directly for one association's board. These are different jobs. A portfolio manager juggles several boards, each with its own governing documents, meeting rhythm and personalities. An on-site or self-managed association manager serves one board and often handles more day-to-day operations, such as amenities, staff and vendors on the property.

Write down which one you are hiring for. If a candidate would answer to a board and a management company's supervisor at once, say so plainly in the posting. Reporting lines that are fuzzy on paper become conflicts in practice.

Write the Scope as Work, Not Adjectives

"Detail-oriented self-starter with excellent communication skills" tells a candidate nothing. List the recurring work instead. For most associations, that includes some mix of the following:

  • Preparing for and attending board meetings, including agendas, packets and follow-up on action items
  • Coordinating annual or special member meetings and elections
  • Working with the association's accountant or bookkeeper on budgets, delinquency tracking and financial reports
  • Soliciting bids, supervising vendors and tracking contract renewals
  • Administering covenant and architectural review processes under the governing documents
  • Responding to owner questions, complaints and violations
  • Coordinating with the association's attorney and insurance agent when issues arise

Then mark which items are core on day one and which the person can grow into. A candidate who sees an honest list can assess their own fit, which saves everyone interview time.

Settle Pay, Schedule and Licensing Questions Early

Do not guess at compensation. Gather current postings for comparable association manager roles in your area, note whether each is portfolio or on-site, and compare the full package: base pay, bonus structure if any, benefits, vehicle or mileage reimbursement, and the expected schedule. Association work often includes evening board meetings, so state how that time is handled, whether through flexible scheduling, time off in lieu or additional pay. Candidates will ask, and a clear answer builds credibility.

Licensing and certification rules for community association managers vary by location and sometimes by employer type. Check with your state regulator and, if needed, your attorney about what applies to the position you are filling, and put any requirement in the posting so unqualified applicants screen themselves out.

Where to Find HOA / Association Manager Candidates

Start With a Specialized Job Board

A posting on a board that serves the property management field reaches people who already identify with this work. You can browse HOA and association manager job listings to see how other employers word their postings, what duties they emphasize and how they describe the reporting structure. Use that as a reality check on your own draft.

Ask Your Professional Network

Some of your best leads will never apply to a posting. Ask people who see association managers work up close:

  • The association's attorney, who knows which managers write clear violation letters and handle records requests properly
  • The accountant or reserve study provider, who sees which managers deliver complete documents on time
  • Landscape, paving and other vendors who work with several communities and hear how managers treat them
  • Board members from neighboring associations, who can tell you what they wish they had in a manager

Referrals carry the same need for verification as any other source. A warm recommendation gets someone into the interview. It does not replace it.

Consider Adjacent Backgrounds

Some strong candidates come from neighboring roles. Assistant managers and administrative coordinators who have supported association managers may be ready to step up. Apartment community managers bring useful skills in budgeting, vendor management, staff supervision and resident relations. The adjustment is real, though. In an association, the "residents" are owners and members, a volunteer board holds authority, and governing documents shape what the manager can and cannot do. If you consider someone from an apartment background, test how they think about that shift rather than assuming it will come naturally.

Use Local Industry Chapters and Events

Local professional chapters, educational seminars and trade events put you in the same room as managers who invest in their field. You do not need a formal recruiting booth. Showing up, introducing your community or company and mentioning an opening works, and it tells you how candidates talk about their own work.

Screening Résumés and First Calls

Association management résumés can look similar, so screen for evidence of the work rather than the title. Look for specifics: the kinds of associations managed (single-family, townhome, condominium, mixed-use), the number of boards the person worked with, and the tasks they owned versus supported. A candidate who says they "oversaw the budget process" should be able to explain what that meant in practice during a phone call.

Use a short first call, ideally the same questions for every candidate, to check these basics:

  • Which association types and sizes have they managed, and in what capacity?
  • Do they understand whether your role is portfolio or on-site, and does that match what they want?
  • What does their typical week look like, and how do they handle evening meetings?
  • Are they aware of any licensing or certification requirements that apply, and what is their status?
  • What are their pay expectations, and do those fit the package you defined?

Pay attention to how candidates describe past boards. Someone who talks about every former board as difficult or foolish may struggle to keep a working relationship with yours. Someone who describes a hard situation fairly, including their own part in it, is showing the judgment you need.

Interviewing for Judgment, Not Just Experience

Use Scenarios That Match Your Community

Association managers spend much of their time in situations where the right answer depends on governing documents, board direction and fairness to owners. Ask candidates how they would approach realistic situations, then listen for process more than a polished answer. For example:

  • An owner is upset about a violation notice and says a neighbor has the same issue. How do they respond and what do they check first?
  • Two board members give conflicting direction on a vendor decision. What do they do?
  • A board member asks the manager to skip a step in a process the governing documents require. How do they respond?
  • A budget variance appears midyear. How do they raise it, with whom and in what format?

For anything touching legal obligations, you want a candidate who knows when to consult the association's attorney and follows approved procedures. Be wary of anyone who treats a board member's instruction as sufficient without checking the documents and applicable rules.

Include the Board or Supervisor Who Will Actually Work With Them

If a board will oversee the hire, include at least one or two members in the final interview, ideally with a clear agenda so the conversation does not become a tour of grievances. If a management company supervisor will manage the person, they should be in the room too. Candidates read the dynamics quickly, and you learn how they communicate with the people they will serve.

Ask Candidates to Do Something

A short work sample reveals more than another round of questions. You might hand over a redacted violation letter and ask for edits, a sample board packet and ask what is missing, or a mock owner email and ask for a reply. Keep it brief and clearly scoped, and do not ask anyone to do free work on your real problems.

A Scorecard You Can Use for Final Interviews

Agree on criteria before the first final interview, and have each interviewer score independently before you compare notes. This keeps the loudest voice from deciding for everyone. Adjust the weights to match whether the role is portfolio or on-site.

  • Governing document fluency: Can the candidate explain how they would find the answer in the declaration, bylaws and rules, and when they would stop and ask the attorney? Strong answers describe a process. Weak answers rely on "what usually works."
  • Board communication: Do they describe giving boards options with recommendations, flagging issues early and documenting direction? Probe for a time they disagreed with a board and how they handled it.
  • Financial literacy: Can they read a budget-to-actual report, spot a delinquency trend and explain it to a non-financial board member in plain language?
  • Vendor and project management: Look for competitive bidding habits, contract tracking and follow-through on inspections and punch lists.
  • Owner relations and fairness: Do they apply rules consistently and stay professional with upset owners? Ask how they document interactions.
  • Organization and follow-through: Based on the work sample and examples, would meeting packets, deadlines and records stay under control with limited supervision?
  • Fit with your structure: Are they comfortable with your reporting lines, schedule and level of autonomy?

Score each item on a simple scale you define in advance, write one sentence of evidence per score, and discuss any item where interviewers differ widely. A large gap usually means the interviewers heard different things or asked different questions, which is worth sorting out before an offer.

Verify Before You Offer

Check References With Specific Questions

Speak with former supervisors and, where possible, a board member from a past association. Ask about the specific tasks the candidate owned, how they handled disagreement, how reliable their reporting was and whether the reference would work with them again. Open-ended praise is common, so ask for examples.

Confirm Credentials With the Issuer

Before relying on any license, certification or designation a candidate lists, confirm its status directly with the regulator or issuing organization instead of the résumé. Ask the issuer about its current rules, and ask yourself whether the credential is relevant to the specific duties you defined. Weigh it alongside documented experience, references and interview performance.

Run Background Checks Through Proper Channels

Association managers often handle financial records, access to owner information and sometimes keys or payment systems. Work with your counsel or HR resource on which screenings are appropriate and legal in your jurisdiction, apply them consistently across finalists and follow the required disclosure and consent steps.

Make the Offer and Onboard With a Plan

Put the Details in Writing

An offer should state the title, reporting line, compensation, benefits, schedule expectations (including evening meetings), any required licensing steps and who covers related costs. For direct board hires, clarify who the employer of record is and who handles supervision day to day. Boards change, so the arrangement should not depend on one person's memory.

Prepare the First Weeks Before Day One

New managers perform better when the groundwork is ready. Assemble a starter package so they can learn the community instead of hunting for documents:

  • The declaration, bylaws, rules and any amendments, plus recent board meeting minutes
  • The current budget, reserve information and recent financial reports
  • Active vendor contracts with renewal dates and contact details
  • Open violations, pending architectural requests and any ongoing legal matters
  • A list of key contacts, including the attorney, accountant, insurance agent and board officers

Schedule early introductions with the board and major vendors, and set a regular check-in for the first few months. Agree on what success looks like at each check-in so feedback is concrete rather than a surprise.

A Frank Look at Role Fit

It helps to be honest with candidates about what the work is like. Association management involves regular evening meetings, volunteer boards whose members may disagree with each other and owners who are emotionally invested in their homes. The people who tend to do well here enjoy mediating, can stay even-tempered under criticism and are comfortable saying "the documents don't allow that" or "let's ask the attorney." Candidates who prefer to work independently with minimal conflict may find the role draining. Telling candidates this upfront protects both sides, and how a candidate responds to it is useful information.

Frequently Asked Questions About Hiring a HOA / Association Manager

Who should be on the interview panel if our board is hiring directly?

Choose a small group, often the president, treasurer and one other member, and give them a shared scorecard and agenda. A panel of the whole board can turn an interview into a debate. If board members are not experienced hiring managers, consider asking the association's attorney or a trusted outside advisor to review the process, particularly the employment terms and screening steps.

Can a candidate from apartment community management succeed in an association role?

Possibly, and the skills in budgeting, vendors and customer service do carry over. The gaps to test are working under a volunteer board, applying governing documents to owners rather than lease terms to residents, and handling member meetings and elections. Ask for specific examples of work that resembles those tasks, and plan extra onboarding around the documents and board relationship.

What should I do if a strong candidate works for a competing management company?

Ask directly whether they are bound by any non-compete, non-solicitation or confidentiality agreement, and ask to see the relevant terms. Have your employment counsel review them before you extend an offer, and make clear that you do not want the candidate to bring proprietary files or client information from their current employer.

Grayson Author Property Management JobsGrayson Turley| Property Management Professional